Wednesday, January 14, 2015

To Kill a Mockingbird: The Film

8. What benefits are there from having a film version of a classic book like To Kill a Mockingbird?

Watching the film based on the novel To Kill a Mockingbird has made me realize how many benefits there are by watching as opposed to just picturing in your mind as you read. Although the movie is not always as good or as detailed as the book, the events that you can see often draw conclusions and answer questions that one might have had about the events in the book. For example, in the novel, the scenes where the children (Scout, Jem, and Dill) were trying to spy on Boo Radley were very hard to imagine. The details that were added into the book were often perplexing seeing as action packed or suspenseful scenes are hard to picture for some people when there are just words. Watching the movie gave me a better understanding as to what had actually happened, and how the children acted and reacted to the attempt at finding Boo Radley. In addition, the trial scene where Tom Robinson and Mayella Ewell were being questioned was very powerful in the book as well as the movie. However, being able to see the reactions on people's faces, the questions being answered by the witnesses, and the suspense built up by waiting for the verdict made me understand the characters more, and it helped me to become more invested in the story. That scene was very important in both the book and the movie, but since there were so many details to be noted in the book, it seemed easier to portray as a film. To Kill a Mockingbird was a book full of very in depth messages and events, which the film version did well to portray and enhance. 

9. They say that the book is always better than the movie. Do you agree or disagree with this statement regarding To Kill a Mockingbird? Why or why not? 

Regarding To Kill a Mockingbird, I agree with the fact that the book is always better than the movie. I thought that the film was a very good depiction of the events and messages in the book. However, although it was good to watch some of the scenes to get a better understanding of the events in the book, there were a lot of big ideas from the book that were left out. There were also some small events from the book that did not need to be included if the big events weren't there. For example, Aunt Alexandra, who was a huge part of the book, was not in the film at all. I didn't know whether it would have made the move too confusing, or that the filmmakers just didn't find it an important enough topic. The book often focused around Scout's style, and how her Aunt wanted to make her more "ladylike." This sent a very valuable message in the book which was completely left out of the movie. Also, there were other messages hidden in the book, like when Jem went to read for Mrs. Dubose, who was a dying old woman. This never happened in the movie, although Mrs. Dubose was shown randomly at the very beginning. I prefer the book over the movie because there were some images I had in my head that were completely altered while watching the film. I enjoyed having to picture certain scenes in my mind, and having to think about what was really happening. After getting a set image in my mind it was hard for it to be altered entirely through watching the movie. I agree with the fact that the novel To Kill a Mockingbird is better than the film based on it. 

No comments:

Post a Comment