Sunday, December 7, 2014

To Kill a Mockingbird (Ch. 16 +17)

Chapters 16 and 17 of To Kill a Mockingbird by Harper Lee raised many questions in my mind that made me want to dive deeper into the text. For example, as Scout describes Atticus' reaction to Aunt Alexandra, she says, "it was a quite digging in, never outright irritation" (157). I found this confusing because Atticus' personality has changed a lot throughout the time that Aunt Alexandra has been living with the Finch's. At first, it seemed as if Alexandra had changed his views on certain things, almost like she was hypnotizing him. For example, when he got mad at Scout, it seemed as if the words he was using was something that would come out of his sister's voice. This quote, however, shows that his outlook on his sister has changed. It seems that he has come to a realization that she was manipulating him, but I am wondering how or when he came to that realization. It brought a question back into my mind from earlier in the book also. I was wondering why Atticus was letting his sister walk all over him, because men during this time period were often very controlling of women. This quote was perplexing, and it made me think more about the characters and plot.

In addition, during the court scene, the judge said, "He's answered the question three times Atticus" (167). This was right after Atticus had asked Heck Tate whether he called a doctor or not after the rape of Mayella. I was having trouble understanding why Atticus would purposely ask this question three times. From the context clues, I am trying to infer that it has something to do with a detail that Atticus might bring up in the trial later, but I did not see how that detail would be relevant. Heck Tate however, did not hesitate to answer the questions. I was wondering if this was because he was completely telling the truth throughout his whole story, or if he had planned an elaborate story to tell as a witness. I was wondering whether or not the judge knew Atticus' plan by asking so many times, seeing as he has been in a courtroom so many times before. I hope to find out later in the trial if Atticus will bring up that conversation again.

No comments:

Post a Comment